Original Article
Early Monday morning, the body of Christine W. Watson, was found mangled on the beach in Amity Village. The cause of death is still under investigation, but a shark attack has not been completely ruled out, according to Martin Brody, Amity police chief.
Watson was reported missing at 6 a.m. Monday by Christopher P. Hoggenbottam III, a sophomore at Trinity college and a former resident of Amity, who she was last seen alive with leaving a beach party at approximately 11 p.m. Sunday night.
Watson and Hoggenbottam “had been drinking heavily and possibly smoking marijuana,” according to witnesses.
Hoggenbottam told investigators that he and Watson decided to go swimming at a remote section of South Beach near the South Beach Shoal bell buoy. He also told investigators that Watson was a member of the varsity swim team at Amity High School and was a lifeguard at the Amity Island YMCA pool in Oak Bluffs. Watson was a resident of Amity.
A search was conducted in the morning after Watson did not return from the water and Hoggenbottam contacted authorities.
Watson’s body was found washed up on the beach and appeared to be “severely mauled by an attacker of unknown origin,” Brody said in a statement.
Watson’s wounds appear to be consistent with those of a motor boating accident, said Dr. Robert Nevin, the medical examiner. There is “no evidence of a shark attack,” said Nevin.
“Everything is a possibility,” said Brody, adding that a shark attack has not been completely ruled out.
Investigators have been questioning local boaters to determine anyone who may have been out on the water last night, said Brody. There are no current leads.
According to Brody, no charges have been filed and the police are continuing their investigation of the incident.
Larry Vaughan, Mayor of Amity, said that there is not much that authorities can do to keep swimmers safer at night because they are taking a risk by swimming in remote locations.
There will be no additional precautionary measures taken for the Fourth of July holiday, said Vaughan.
The beaches of Amity village “will remain open for swimming pending the outcome of the investigation,” said Brody in a statement.
Updated Article
Alex B. Kitner was killed at Village Beach at 2 p.m. today in what appears to have been an unprovoked shark attack, according to Martin Brody, Amity police chief. Alex’s death may be linked to the death of Christine W. Watson, who had previously been thought to have been killed in a motor boat accident.
Alex Kitner, 10, a resident of Amity, had been seen “floating on a rubber raft,” according to witnesses, when the attack occurred. The damaged raft floated to shore with what appeared to be a large bite out of it, but Alex’s body has not been recovered.
Watson, 17, also a resident of Amity was last seen alive at 11 p.m. Sunday with Christopher P. Hoggenbottam, a sophomore at Trinity College and former Amity resident, when the two left a beach party and decided to go swimming at a remote section of South Beach.
When Watson never returned from the water, Hoggenbottam contacted authorities around 6 a.m. Monday. Shortly after, Watson’s “mangled body was found… washed up on the beach,” said Brody in a statement.
Examinations showed that Watson’s wounds appeared to be consistent with those of a motor boating accident, said Dr. Robert Nevin, the medical examiner. There is “no evidence of a shark attack,” Nevin said.
Larry Vaughan, mayor of Amity, agreed with Nevin and said that there would be no additional precautionary measures taken to protect swimmers because Watson’s death appeared to have been a simple boating accident.
In his original statement, Brody said that the “beaches will remain open for swimming pending the outcome of the investigation.”
This afternoon, Brody released an updated statement. “We now believe that it may be possible that the Watson death could also maybe have been linked to possible shark activities in the vicinity of Amity. That investigation is ongoing.”
At 6 p.m. today, a special meeting will be held in Town Hall by Brody; Amity mayor Larry Vaughan; and the Amity Board of Selectmen. New business scheduled in the agenda includes a discussion of Chief Brody’s plan to close the beaches on July 4; Kitner family reward of $3,000 for capture of perpetrators; and an offer by grizzled old fisherman Ben Quint to hunt down the shark thought to be the vile perpetrator of this tragic incident.